Many viewers felt like Swift was singing directly to Travis Kelce during this performance. “This love is REAL,” one fan commented on a fan-recording, adding, “Singing these two [songs] with Travis in the crowd is pure romance.” Another fan replied to a different video, writing, “Trav was in attendance this was definitely a love mash up.”

Taylor Swift gave fans a thrill when she performed an unexpected song with a special guest during her “Eras Tour” show in New Orleans Oct. 26. Towards the end of the concert, during the part of the set that fans have dubbed “surprise song o’clock,