According to Forbes, “there was never supposed to be a season 2.” Writer Paul Tassi added, “And unlike other streaming services, where if a miniseries does well enough, it might twist itself into a second season, that is not likely to happen here. It’s probably almost impossible.”

In the wake of the Agatha All Along’s season 1 finale, questions about the miniseries possibly breaking its format and getting a season 2 have been raised